PKI Health Check
Service

PKI Health Check

An independent, vendor-neutral assessment of your PKI that identifies risk, validates controls and sets out prioritised improvements.

Why 

What Is a PKI Health Check?

A PKI health check is an independent assessment of your public key infrastructure. It reviews the architecture, configuration, operational processes and governance that keep your certificates trusted and your services running. It establishes how your PKI actually operates today, identifies risks and misconfigurations before they cause incidents, and sets out prioritised recommendations aligned to your business objectives.

Unsung's PKI health check covers:

  • certificate authorities, registration and validation services
  • certificate templates and profiles
  • revocation and directory services integration
  • backups, monitoring and documentation
  • readiness for what comes next, including Zero Trust, 47-day certificates and post-quantum cryptography

It applies whether your PKI is built on Microsoft Active Directory Certificate Services (AD CS), EJBCA or another platform.

Why a PKI Health Check Matters

Certificate-related outages disrupt critical services, and poorly governed PKI environments create security vulnerabilities and compliance exposure. Without regular assessment, organisations carry hidden risks: expired certificates, weak cryptographic standards, inadequate monitoring or insufficient documentation.

Most of those risks stay invisible until something breaks. In the estates we assess, the number of certificates found consistently exceeds the number the organisation had on record. The ones nobody knows about are the ones that cause outages.

A health check provides assurance that your cryptographic foundation is fit for purpose and meets regulatory requirements. It:

  • highlights areas of concern before they become incidents
  • validates existing controls
  • identifies where automation or process change would reduce effort

The timing matters. Public TLS certificate lifetimes are falling to 47 days, taking renewal volume up roughly eightfold. The post-quantum transition will require an inventory most organisations do not yet hold. For anyone planning digital transformation, adopting Zero Trust, or preparing for either of those changes, a health check establishes whether the foundation is ready.

PKI is also a key enabler for many business priorities: cloud adoption, IoT and automation, DevOps, Zero Trust and the connected workforce. It is equally central to compliance with frameworks such as ISO 27001, Cyber Essentials Plus, PCI DSS and GDPR. When the PKI is weak, all of those initiatives carry risk.

Signs You Need a PKI Health Check

  • An audit finding relating to certificates, key management or PKI governance.
  • A root or issuing CA approaching expiry, with uncertainty about what depends on it.
  • AD CS running on an ageing or unsupported Windows Server version.
  • Recent certificate-related outages or authentication failures.
  • Loss of key staff who held knowledge of how the PKI was built.
  • A merger, acquisition or divestment that brings in an unfamiliar PKI estate.
  • No reliable certificate inventory, or certificates tracked in spreadsheets.
  • Plans for 47-day certificates, Zero Trust or PQC that depend on the PKI being ready.
  • Documentation that no longer matches how the environment actually operates.

For a quick first view, see How mature is your PKI? A framework for self-assessment.

What

What a PKI Health Check Covers

Our health check identifies vulnerabilities, assesses operational efficiency and establishes whether your cryptographic environment aligns with security standards and business objectives. The analysis provides a clear path to improved resilience and compliance.

PKI underpins digital trust across your organisation, from authentication and encryption to code signing and secure communications. Yet many organisations have limited visibility into the health of that estate, which leads to outages, compliance gaps and unmanaged risk.

We evaluate cryptographic infrastructure across governance, process, technology and operational maturity. We identify misconfigurations, assess risk exposure and provide prioritised recommendations that support informed decision-making and investment.

Our approach is vendor-neutral and consultative. We assess against industry standards and your specific business requirements, delivering findings that strengthen security posture and reduce operational friction. You get an independent assessment, not a platform recommendation dressed up as one.

Our case studies show what this produces in practice, across engineering, healthcare and systems integrator environments.

Our Approach: Extract, Evaluate, Enhance

Every health check follows the same three-stage method, so findings are consistent, evidence-based and comparable over time.

1. Extract: Understand Your PKI

We start by understanding:

  • your architecture and business use cases
  • your strategic priorities and key concerns
  • how certificates are used across the organisation

We then review the areas that determine how well the PKI performs:

  • enrolment and certificate issuance processes
  • certificate lifecycle management
  • revocation
  • backup processes
  • technical resilience and scalability
  • technical components, configuration and alignment with common practice

2. Evaluate: Gather the Evidence

We work with your operational teams to collect evidence directly from the technical components that deliver your PKI service:

  • Environmental sweep: information on issued certificates, templates and configuration.
  • Permissions analysis: groups, certificate template permissions and access rights.
  • System specifications: platform, software and firmware details.
  • Certificate discovery: identification of the certificates actually in use across the estate, including those that are not on record.

3. Enhance: Assess, Grade and Recommend

We then assess each area in detail:

  • architecture and CA configuration
  • revocation check systems
  • certificate templates
  • Active Directory integration
  • backups
  • monitoring and alerting
  • documentation and process
  • certificate enrolment and issuance
  • certificate monitoring and discovery

Where it adds value, the health check can be extended with a strategic assessment, target architecture and requirements, and a review of candidate technologies.

Areas Assessed

A full health check considers the following areas, where applicable to your environment:

  • Architecture: CA hierarchy, trust model, offline root CA security and issuing CA design.
  • CA, RA and VA configuration: certificate authority settings, registration authority practices and validation authority services.
  • Revocation: CRL distribution points (CDP), delta CRLs, Authority Information Access (AIA) locations and OCSP responders.
  • Certificate templates and profiles: template design, permissions, validity periods, key sizes and algorithms.
  • Enrolment and issuance: auto-enrolment, web enrolment, NDES and SCEP, ACME, EST and approval workflows.
  • Certificate lifecycle management: inventory, discovery, renewal, expiry monitoring and automation.
  • Directory services integration: Active Directory integration, Group Policy and smart card authentication.
  • Key management and rotation: private key protection, hardware security modules, key archival and recovery.
  • Backups and technical resilience: backup processes, restore testing and disaster recovery readiness.
  • Monitoring and alerting: coverage of CA, CRL, OCSP and certificate expiry.
  • Documentation and process maturity: Certificate Policy (CP), Certification Practice Statement (CPS) and operating procedures.
  • Scalability: the capacity of the service to support growth in certificates, devices and use cases.
  • Quantum preparedness and crypto-agility: algorithm use, key lengths and readiness for post-quantum migration.

AD CS Health Check

Many organisations run their PKI on Microsoft Active Directory Certificate Services. AD CS is capable and widely deployed, but it is also one of the most common sources of PKI risk. Typical problems include:

  • certificate templates with excessive enrolment permissions
  • CAs on ageing Windows Server versions
  • unmonitored CRL publication
  • configuration that has drifted from its original design

Our AD CS health check reviews CA configuration, template permissions, enrolment services, AIA and CDP publication, auto-enrolment and Group Policy, and backup and recovery. It also covers hardening against known AD CS attack paths. Read more in Active Directory Certificate Services in modern IT.

How

How We Deliver It

We deliver health checks in standard and lite formats, tailored to the scope and depth your organisation requires. Our team of over 20 PKI specialists brings extensive cybersecurity experience from government and enterprise environments, with many holding SC and DV clearance.

  • PKI Health Check Lite: a focused assessment of your core PKI, typically delivered over around 10 days. Suited to organisations that need a fast, evidence-based view of risk.
  • Standard PKI Health Check: a deeper assessment for larger or more complex estates. It can be extended with strategic assessment, target architecture and candidate technology review.

The Process

  1. Kick-off. We introduce the team, walk through the process with your stakeholders and agree outputs and expectations.
  2. Questionnaire. Technical and business questions are sent to key stakeholders.
  3. Artefact review. We request key artefacts, which can be securely emailed or viewed by screen share.
  4. Technical review. We work with your operational teams to run tools and checks that collect information from the technical components delivering your PKI service.
  5. Analysis. All information and questionnaire responses are analysed.
  6. Report. The health check report is published.
  7. Closure session. Our consultants take your stakeholders through the findings and recommendations and answer questions.

What We Need From You

Typical inputs include:

  • PKI architecture diagrams and CA hierarchy details
  • CA configuration information
  • certificate template or profile details
  • certificate inventory or discovery outputs
  • CRL and OCSP configuration
  • HSM and CLM platform details
  • monitoring and alerting information
  • backup and restore procedures, DR plans and test evidence
  • incident history, change history and known issues
  • CP/CPS documents, SOPs and operational procedures
  • vendor support details
  • platform, software and firmware versions
  • access and permissions information

Missing inputs will not stop the health check. Where information is not available, recommendations are based on documented assumptions for you to validate.

Current State Analysis

We review your PKI setup, including certificate authority configuration, Active Directory Certificate Services implementation, Authority Information Access locations and certificate lifecycle management.

We assess CRL stores, delta CRL distribution, revocation mechanisms, backup processes and monitoring capability. In enterprise environments we verify Active Directory integration, evaluate smart card authentication configuration and review certificate templates. This establishes a baseline of how the environment actually operates, rather than how it was designed to.

The analysis contributes to a broader cryptographic inventory, documenting not just certificates but the algorithms, libraries and key material your systems depend on. A cryptographic bill of materials extends that into a maintained baseline as the environment changes.

Risk Assessment and Findings

Vulnerabilities, misconfigurations and process weaknesses are documented and categorised by risk level. We evaluate certificate validity periods, expiration tracking and protection of key material. Each finding includes context, potential impact and recommended mitigation, so you can prioritise remediation against risk appetite and available resources.

Findings are graded on a clear three-level scale:

  • High risk: items that would result in significant harm to the organisation.
  • Medium risk: items that should be addressed because they are likely to affect security posture or operational excellence.
  • Low risk: items that go against best practice or create inefficiencies, including manual processes that could lead to human error.

Recommendations are prioritised in the same way:

  • High priority: items that will severely affect achievement of strategic priorities or the performance of the PKI service.
  • Medium priority: items that could affect strategic priorities, and recommended service improvements.
  • Low priority: items for awareness in relation to strategic priorities, alignment with common practice, or lower-value improvements.

Read more in Inside a PKI health check: how we assess, grade and report on your estate.

Governance and Compliance Review

We assess Certificate Policy, Certification Practice Statement and operational documentation for completeness, accuracy and adherence to compliance frameworks. We verify that documented procedures are actually implemented. The gap between the two is where audit findings usually originate.

Operational Efficiency Evaluation

Manual processes and performance issues are identified, with recommendations for automation, tooling or workflow change that reduce human error and improve service reliability. Where a platform change is warranted, our CLM vendor and licensing evaluation guide covers how we approach that comparison.

Strategic Alignment

We evaluate how well your PKI supports your technology roadmap and security strategy. We highlight gaps or enhancements needed for cloud adoption, Zero Trust implementation or post-quantum readiness. Building crypto-agility into the architecture is what turns the next cryptographic change into a managed programme rather than a rebuild.

Health Check Report

The final report is written for both technical and executive audiences. It includes:

  • a current state summary
  • key findings
  • a risk review with high, medium and low risk items
  • prioritised recommendations and improvement areas, covering service scalability and resilience; CA, RA and VA configuration; revocation; directory services integration; backups; operational and governance processes; certificate enrolment and issuance; certificate lifecycle management; and quantum preparedness
  • discovered certificates

The report informs remediation plans and investment cases. It is followed by a closure session with your stakeholders.

Health Checks Within the PKI Support Service

A health check is also the foundation of Unsung's PKI Support Service. Every support engagement begins with one, so our specialists understand your estate before they support it. Strategic Assurance customers receive an annual health check, and all customers on Enhanced Assurance and above receive quarterly PKI service health reviews to track risk over time.

What Happens Next

A health check is an assessment, not a commitment to anything further. Where remediation is needed we can support it through consultancy, design and build or managed operations. Alternatively, you can hand the findings to your own team to act on. Our obsolescence remediation case study shows how assessment findings translate into a delivery programme.

Case Studies

Talk to our team to discuss scope and timescales.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a PKI health check?

A PKI health check is a comprehensive assessment designed to identify vulnerabilities, assess operational performance, and verify alignment with cybersecurity standards and business needs. It evaluates cryptographic infrastructure across four dimensions: governance, processes, technology, and operational maturity.

Why do organisations need a PKI health check?

Certificate-related outages can disrupt critical services, whilst poorly governed PKI environments create security vulnerabilities and compliance exposure. Many organisations lack visibility into their cryptographic infrastructure, leading to potential compliance failures and unmanaged risks. A health check identifies these issues before incidents occur.

What does a PKI health check assess?

The assessment includes current state analysis reviewing certificate authority configuration and Active Directory integration, risk assessment documenting vulnerabilities categorised by severity, governance review evaluating policies and compliance framework alignment, operational efficiency identifying automation opportunities, and strategic alignment assessing PKI readiness for digital transformation initiatives.

How does a PKI health check prepare for zero trust and post-quantum cryptography?

The health check assesses PKI readiness for strategic initiatives like Zero Trust adoption and post-quantum cryptography transitions. It identifies misconfigurations, evaluates risk exposure, and delivers vendor-neutral recommendations to help organisations prepare for these critical security transformations.

How long does a PKI health check take?

A PKI Health Check Lite is typically delivered over around 10 days, from kick-off to report. A standard health check for a larger or more complex estate takes longer, and the timescale is agreed during scoping.

Will a PKI health check disrupt live services?

A health check is designed to avoid disruption. Evidence is gathered through questionnaires, artefact reviews, and tools and checks run with your operational teams. Artefacts can be shared by secure email or viewed by screen share.

What is the difference between a standard and a lite PKI health check?

The lite health check is a focused, fast assessment of your core PKI. The standard health check goes deeper for larger or more complex estates, and can be extended with strategic assessment, target architecture and candidate technology review.

What do we receive at the end of a PKI health check?

You receive a report written for technical and executive audiences, with a current state summary, risk-graded findings, prioritised recommendations and discovered certificates, followed by a closure session with our consultants.